We offer 50% cash, 60% trade, and 70% consignment

Sell at our hobby shop in Evansville, IN

Sell Your Memorabilia/Cards

Contact Us

Please upload pictures of front and back of items 

All fields marked with an asterisk * are required

It can take time to find the best possible deal for your best trading cards. But you don’t have to do the work listing and selling your cards. You can let Clever Bay Sports & Gaming handle it for you.


We run the largest trading card shop in the tri-state area, and we’ll be happy to sell your trading cards on consignment. We’ll do the work selling your item directly from our consignment shop so you can just relax and collect your earnings.


Learn more about our trading card consignment services by submitting the form above.

Contact our consignment shop today at 812-777-5163 to get started.

How the process works

We make consignment simple and straightforward. All you have to do is…

A white check mark in a black circle on a white background.

Fill out a form to get an estimated price for your card or memorabilia

A white check mark in a black circle on a white background.

Submit contact information, photos and any other relevant information

A white check mark in a black circle on a white background.

Wait for your item to sell and collect your money

Two football cards are sitting on a table next to each other.